| Adrenaline Valut: Keith Durocher's review [2/5] includes screenshots. "Shock value for the sake of shock value is no premise for a full-length game." |
| CNN.com - Review: 'Postal 2' more offensive than fun: By Marc Saltzman. "It makes 'Vice City' look like a Disney cartoon." |
| Eternal Damnation: A modification which adds new features and functionalities including weapons, enemies, maps, and a new storyline. |
| Game Industry News: Reviewed by John Breeden, score: 5 out of 5. |
| Gamer's Hell: Dennis S review [7.5/10] includes screenshots. "Postal 2 is a game that some might like, while some might hate." |
| GameSpot: Erik Wolpaw review [4.8/10] includes screenshots. "Postal 2 strings together a bunch of violent novelties without ever constructing a compelling game for them to support." |
| Gameworld: Postal 2 Review: [82%] Review by Michael Bordelon. "While the game is indeed violent, it remains cartoonish and even humorous at times." |