| ActionTrip: MechCommander 2: Reviewed, [71/100]. "MechCommander 2 is, unfortunately a game with no soul." |
| Apollo Guide: Mech Commander: Reviewed by Gareth Dickson, [82/100]. "The game is a success, and worthwhile for anyone interested in the MechWarrior series or tactical combat games." |
| Armchair Empire: MechCommander 2: Reviewed by: Omni, [8.6/10]. "There's something very appealing about 60-ton mechanized warriors blowing things up and making money at the same time." |
| Game Revolution: Mech Commander 2: Reviewed by Johnny B., [B+]. "It does everything it has to and does it well, but it doesn't do anything new." |
| GamePro.com: Mech Commander 2: Reviewed by Jake The Snake, [4/5]. "Fans of giant robots and strategy games will enjoy stomping around in this one." |
| GameSpot: MechCommander: Reviewed by Greg Kasavin, [7.3/10]. "A solid effort right down to its glossy packaging and colorful documentation." |
| GameSpot: MechCommander 2: Reviewed by Bruce Geryk, [7.7/10]. "a significant improvement upon the original in numerous ways, particularly in the interface." |
| GameSpot: MechCommander Gold: Reviewed by Greg Kasavin, [7.5/10]. "Its limited scope will feel frustratingly familiar to MechCommander veterans, although newcomers should enjoy the game in its more refined state." |
| GameSpy.com: MechCommander 2: Reviewed by William Abner, [84/100]. "MechCommander 2 is a winner. If you have the horses to run it, it's worth every penny." |
| Gamezilla: MechCommander 2: Reviewed by William Brandt, [Fans Only]. "I'm positive that anyone who has played any of the prior Mech games will really have some fun with this one." |
| GameZone.com: MechCommander 2: Reviewed by Immortal, [9.3/10]. "Microsoft got the formula right, and it shows." |
| IGN: MechCommander 2: Reviewed by Steve Butts, [8.2/10]. " The linear single player game still offers a bit more variety than usual." |
| The Adrenaline Vault: MechCommander: Reviewed by Chris Harding, [2/5]. "I'm happy to say I beat Mechcommander. I'm happier to say that I won't have to play it again anytime soon." |
| The Adrenaline Vault: MechCommander 2: Reviewed by Bob Mandel, [4/5]. "MechCommander 2 is a very good stab, much better than its predecessor, aimed at fulfilling this need." |
| The Adrenaline Vault: MechCommander Gold: Reviewed by Chris Harding, [3.5/5]. "While MechCommander Gold is dramatically better than its older brother, for all intents and purposes, it is merely the same game with some new missions and one huge patch." |
| The Electric Playground: Reviewed by Scott Steinberg, [7.5/10]. "Layers of depth and beauty characterize an honestly memorable and fun virtual war zone." |
| The Gamers Temple: MechCommander 2: Review, [85%]. "An excellent and enjoyable tactical combat game for those who don't enjoy base building or resource gathering." |
Classical
