All-Reviews.com - Bachelor No. 2: LarryG's review: "... more tasteful, adult pop but it's hardly ground-breaking." Rated 2 out of 4 stars.
Ink Blot Magazine: Bachelor No. 2: Beth Bachtold's review: "...a beautifully melodic foray into human nature and all its inherent scenarios - good, bad, ugly."
Metacritic: Bachelor No. 2: Multiple critic and user reviews; album earns a metascore of 87.
MusicOMH.com: Aimee Mann - Bachelor No 2: John Murphy's review: "...mostly quality stuff from an inspired songwriter."
Nude as the News: Troy Carpenter's review: "Bachelor's tunes are Mann's most mature yet." Rated 8 out of 10.
PopMatters: Colm Ward's review: "Like a quick hit of Sambuca, it goes in sweet but leaves a trail of fire as it sinks down."