PopMatters.com: Mariah Carey - Greatest Hits: Devon Powers' review: "the artifacts of Mariah's career were not the result of hocus pocus that looks dastardly in retrospect. They were bona fide monetary successes, buoyed by popularity that knew no bounds."
UKMIX: Mariah Carey - Greatest Hits: Marvin van der Weyde's review: "As a whole the CDs are not bad, however they form a proof of how Mariah is going downhill"